Doctoral dissertation · UBC

Sensing people in nature

A systematic map of the technologies used to observe human presence, movement, and activity across parks, green space, and protected areas — and where the methods are heading.

246
studies included
2010-2024
span
~24,530
records screened
3
behavioural dimensions
01 · The search

From 24,530 records to 246 studies

Two databases, screened in stages against the inclusion criteria. Most records fell away at title and abstract; 246 studies form the final corpus.

PRISMA selection · WoS + Scopus
Records identifiedn = 24,530WoS 10,139 + Scopus 14,391After de-duplicationn = 12,078screened by title−12,452Abstract screeningn = 526titles passed−11,552Full-text assessedn = 271abstracts passed−255Studies includedn = 246−25
02 · Growth

A young field, accelerating — but still sensor-bound

Publications take off after 2018 and peak at 43 in 2022. Yet computer vision (terracotta) and hybrid (violet) appear only after 2019 and stay a thin band on top — the surge is almost entirely sensor-based.

Publications per year, by method · n = 246
01020304020102012201420162018202020222024publications / year, by methodSensorHybridVision
03 · Methods

The field leans on location sensing

Of 246 studies, 196 (80%) rely on sensors — overwhelmingly GPS. Only 28 use computer vision and 22 blend both. GPS alone accounts for 183 of 246 studies.

Sensor vs Vision vs Hybrid · share of 246
Sensor196 · 80%Hybrid22 · 9%Vision28 · 11%
Primary capture technology · studies
GPS Apps121GPS Devices62Computer Vision39Manual (PPGIS)8Passive infrared4Wearable (accelerometer)4Counter3Wi-Fi / Bluetooth / Beacon2Motion sensor2Seismic sensor1
GPS apps and devices dominate; computer vision (39) and wireless presence sensing (Wi-Fi / Bluetooth, 2) are the emerging frontier.
04 · The evidence map

Where the gaps are

Sensors cover every behavioural dimension, owning movement (70) and presence (122). Vision and hybrid methods cluster in activity & interaction (22, 20) — recognising what people do — but barely touch movement (5, 2). Those faint, dashed cells are the open frontier.

Behavioural dimension × method · bubble = studies
WHERE THE EVIDENCE SITSstudies addressing each behavioural dimension, by methodSENSORVISIONHYBRIDPresence122157Movement705gap2gapActivity and Interaction952220
A study may address more than one dimension, so columns can exceed each method's total. Dashed bubbles mark sparsely-covered combinations.
05 · The pipeline

Technology → algorithm → behaviour

How the corpus flows from sensing hardware, through the algorithm family that interprets it, to the behaviour it ultimately measures. GPS feeds location-based pipelines into all three dimensions; cameras feed computer-vision pipelines almost entirely into activity recognition.

Method pipeline · flows = studies
GPSCamera / CVOther sensorsManualWearableWi-Fi / BTLocation-basedComputer VisionHybridActivity and Interaction (97)Presence (92)Movement (57)TECHNOLOGYALGORITHMBEHAVIOUR
Credit

Scoping review

Research lead

Mingze Chen

Study design, screening, coding, analysis & visualization

Supervision & committee

Dr. Keunhyun Park

Supervisor

Dr. Angela Rout

Dr. Guangyu Wang

UNDER Lab ↗

Method & data

Systematic search · Web of Science + Scopus

246 studies · 2010-2024